Welcome to Rabbit Holes & Meditations!
Nov. 22, 2026

Aligned With What?

Aligned With What?
Aligned With What?
Rabbit Holes & Meditations
Aligned With What?

About a week ago we posted Clean Water, a short story about Dr. Nathan Pryce. He’s a scientist trying to make an AI good by feeding its best answers back into itself, round after round, until it comes out clean. In this episode we talk about what that story is really about.

It began with a debate. Some of the people building artificial intelligence put the odds of catastrophe at ten, even twenty-five percent. Others call that guesswork. They argued over thresholds, red lines, and whether a superintelligent machine can ever be controlled. Underneath all of it was one word the industry uses for its biggest problem: alignment, meaning teaching a machine to value what we value.

But nobody in the room asked the obvious next question. Aligned to what? If the machine learns from mankind, and the people correcting it are mankind too, what standard is anyone measuring against?

We follow that question through the story: Nathan’s Loop, Mara’s warning that the machine was “learning what you picked,” and a box that could quote Job 14:4 word for word and still not take its cure. Then there’s Ruth, the night custodian, who knew what Nathan didn’t: you can strain dirty water all night and only get finer mud.

📖 Key passages: Job 14:4; Luke 6:45; Psalm 115:8; Amos 7:7–8; Ezekiel 36:25–26; John 4:14

🎧 Listen to Clean Water first: https://www.rabbitholesandmeditations.com/clean-water/